Mitford's longtime Episcopal priest, Father Tim, retires; yet new challenges and adventures await when he agrees to serve as interim minister of a small church on Whitecap Island. He and his wife soon find that Whitecap has its own unforgettable characters: a church organist with a mysterious past, a lovelorn bachelor placing personal ads, a mother battling paralyzing depression. They also find that Mitford is never far away when circumstances "back home" keep their phone ringing off the hook.